How to Make the BEST Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches

By Christine Bean


Your favorite summertime dessert is getting an upgrade! Grab your favorite soft and chewy Bean Bag Bakery cookies and a QUART of ice cream and you’ll have a treat that kids of all ages will go crazy over!  Follow these 6 easy steps to make the BEST cookie ice cream sandwich you’ll ever sink your teeth into!


Step 1
Pick 8 of your favorite Bean Bag Bakery cookies and lay 4 of them on a flat surface with the flat part of the cookie facing up.

Step 2
Grab your favorite quart of ice cream (make sure it’s super cold!). Bean Bag Bakery’s cookies are SO big you need to upgrade your ice cream from a pint to a quart for this recipe hack! Lay the quart of ice cream on its side. Using a sharp knife, cut the quart into 4 equal sections.

Step 3
Peel the carton pieces away from each section of the ice cream, and place each section on top of a cookie.

Step 4
Place another Bean Bag Bakery cookie on top of the ice cream to make it a sandwich!

Step 5
Roll your ice cream sandwich in a topping to up the decadence!  (think sprinkles, mini chocolate chips, walnuts… the options are endless!)

Step 6
Close your eyes and take a big bite out of this chewy, creamy, match made in heaven!


Get your favorite, homemade cookies for your ice cream cookie sandwiches shipped right to your door!

Since 1977!

The Bean Bag Deli & Catering Co. has been serving-up the best cookies ever at our storefront, and now we are bringing them to you!

Free Shipping!

On all orders over $35. We also ship fresh treats the next business day!

A little cookie goes a long way!

The Bean Bag Bakery has donated countless cookies to local charities and organizations.